Bristol Green Party Logo

Thursday, 20th Jul 2017

Green councillors question financial logic of cuts to tree maintenance

At the Members’ Forum in a Full Council meeting this week, Green councillor Carla Denyer asked the Mayor about cuts to Bristol’s street trees budget.

Councillor Denyer submitted joint questions with Green Councillor Clive Stevens [1] which noted several issues raised by the Bristol TreeForum:

-          The Council’s Highways Department did not consult the Council’s arboricultural officers, the TreeForum or any other relevant experts about street trees before making their decision to reduce the budget by 78%, which would effectively mean ceasing most tree maintenance.

-          The Highways department are justifying cuts by saying that they will maintain the minimum statutory service, regularly checking trees every few years, however, this is not cost-efficient as regular pollarding would be cheaper (a point on which horticultural experts agree [2]).

-          There has been no costed business case or risk assessment for the budget cuts.

The last point may be particularly significant as cuts to tree maintenance could potentially result in public damages, for example caused by trees falling on property, subsidence or people tripping over exposed roots, which the council could then be liable for.

Councillor Denyer also asked the Mayor whether the Council’s insurer (Zurich) was consulted over the decision to cut tree maintenance, and whether the insurance would remain valid to cover claims following the budget reductions. The Mayor was unable to answer the question, and promised a response in writing (at the time of writing this has not been received).

Speaking after the Full Council, Councillor Denyer said “I look forward to the Mayor’s response and hope it will shed some light on the issue of insurance. But I’m really worried that nobody in the Highways Department thought to run their proposals past any relevant experts before presenting them to Councillors. Quite aside from the huge value that street trees give to the city in terms of air quality, providing shade and improving wellbeing for residents, there is a simple financial issue here. Any savings made from reducing the maintenance budget could easily be wiped out by a couple of claims against the Council for injuries or damage to private property.”

“The Mayor has assured me that there will be a consultation before these proposals are decided on – that is a small comfort at least. However, given that most of the Council’s recent consultations have been about how to cut services, not whether to cut them, we do not intend to let up on this until we have received proper answers.”

 

  1. Councillor Stevens initially raised concerns over these proposals in April: http://www.bristolpost.co.uk/news/bristol-news/flood-safety-fear-council-slash-33426
  2. http://www.hortweek.com/council-warned-false-economy-abandoning-pollarding/arboriculture/article/1439148
Greens welcome Mayors uturn on council tax scheme

Greens welcome Mayor's u-turn on council tax scheme

Greens welcome Mayor's u-turn on council tax scheme

Green MEP challenge Bristol and South West MPs  back a ban on Nuclear Weapons

Green MEP challenge Bristol and South West MPs – back a ban on Nuclear Weapons

Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has today thrown down a challenge to the region’s sitting MPs to back a ban on Nuclear Weapons. The challenge comes after none of the regions MPs backed an Early Day Motion (EDM) tabled by Green Party Co-Leader, Caroline Lucas MP [1].

We must Stop Brexit says Bristols Green MEP

We must "Stop Brexit" says Bristol's Green MEP

Molly Scott Cato, Bristol's Green MEP and Green Party speaker on Brexit, has reaffirmed a commitment to a ratification referendum at the Party’s conference in Harrogate and has told members it is the best way to reverse the decision to leave the EU.

New figures show unsafe and illegal air pollution getting worse in Bristol

New figures show unsafe and illegal air pollution “getting worse” in Bristol

New official government figures submitted to the European Commission, show that the government has failed to make any significant progress in tackling air pollution since a court ordered it to 18 months ago.

Council refusing to explain legal basis for its council tax consultation

Council refusing to explain legal basis for its council tax consultation

Bristol’s Green councillors today called on the council to provide evidence to support its decision to continue with a controversial consultation on cuts to council tax support.

Green Cllr raises concerns over Council and Home Office targeting of migrants

Green Cllr raises concerns over Council and Home Office targeting of migrants

Green Councillor Cleo Lake has raised concerns at new funding received by Bristol City Council which she fears could be used to further marginalise vulnerable and homeless migrants, betraying Bristol’s status as a ‘Sanctuary City’.

Bristols Green MEP condemns deplorable violence against LGBT community

Bristol's Green MEP condemns ‘deplorable’ violence against LGBT community

Bristol's Green MEP condemns ‘deplorable’ violence against LGBT community in Azerbaijan

Government running scared of its own Brexit impact studies

Government running scared of its own Brexit impact studies

Molly Scott Cato, Bristol's Green MEP, who has been challenging ministers to release secret government studies into the impacts of Brexit, has accused the government of running scared of its own findings.

Tell the Council to protect citys poorest say Greens

Tell the Council to protect city's poorest, say Greens

Tell the Council to protect city's poorest, say Greens

Election Candidates for Bristol West

Election Candidates for Bristol West

We're getting prepared for future elections - Local and National, starting with selecting candidates for Bristol West

Wind power is cheaper than nuclear

Wind power is cheaper than nuclear

MEP challenges South West MPs to unite against Hinkley and embrace a new ‘Green Industrial Revolution’

Councillor Cleo Lake speaks at Saturdays march against austerity

Councillor Cleo Lake speaks at Saturday's march against austerity

"End austerity now, or else. Stop the cuts now, or else. Social justice now, or else. And I predict that the ‘all else’ will be boycotts, strikes, and a return to the Occupy movement."

Decision on Broadmead redevelopment delayed following opposition from Green councillors

Decision on Broadmead redevelopment delayed following opposition from Green councillors

After local campaigners and Green Party councillors successfully highlighted the air pollution and traffic impacts of the proposed development plan, a City Hall planning committee rejected the proposed car park and its access through Brunswick Square.

Join us in protest against austerity an open letter to the People of Bristol

Join us in protest against austerity: an open letter to the People of Bristol

On Saturday 9th September, Green party members will be joining Bristolians from many different organisations and none, to stand up for our city and call for an end to austerity.

Council to go ahead with controversial Council Tax consultation

Council to go ahead with controversial Council Tax consultation

Almost three weeks after Bristol Green Councillors raised the possibility of the Council’s consultation on cuts to the council tax reduction scheme potentially being illegal, the Council has responded.

Cost of Brexit warning from Bristols Green MEP

Cost of Brexit warning from Bristol's Green MEP

With the so-called ‘divorce settlement’ a major sticking point in negotiations over the UK’s future relationship with the EU, Molly Scott Cato, who is Bristol's MEP and the Green Party's speaker on Brexit and on economics, has warned that a ‘cliff edge Brexit’ could be more costly to the UK than the cost of withdrawal from the EU.

Green councillors raise alarm over Broadmead expansion plans

Green councillors raise alarm over Broadmead expansion plans

Green councillors are concerned about the impact on congestion and air quality of proposed plans to redevelop the Broadmead shopping area in the City Centre.

March to End Austerity on 9 September 2017

March to End Austerity on 9 September 2017

Supporting the Bristol-wide demonstration being organised by the Bristol People's Assembly.

Council Tax consultation immoral and probably illegal say Greens

Council Tax consultation immoral and probably illegal, say Greens

The Bristol Green Group of councillors have today called on the Mayor to re-examine the Council’s ongoing consultation on cuts to the Council Tax Reduction Scheme as they believe it may be illegal.

Greens fight back over Mayors MetroBus comments

Greens fight back over Mayor's MetroBus comments

Green councillors have challenged the Mayor over comments made during Tuesday’s cabinet meeting, when he implied that responsibility for the project’s cost increases lay with Councillor Charlie Bolton.

Green councillor challenges Broadmead parking expansion

Green councillor challenges Broadmead parking expansion

At a City Hall cabinet meeting today Councillor Jerome Thomas raised concerns about the environmental and health impacts of the proposed expansion of Cabot Circus at Broadmead, which could include hundreds of additional new car parking spaces.

Setting the record straight on Mayors protest

Setting the record straight on Mayor’s protest

Bristol Post letters section: Green Group leader Eleanor Combley challenges coverage of the Core Cities approach to central government.

Bristol report shows UK rush to incinerate will undermine recycling

Bristol report shows UK rush to incinerate will undermine recycling

A new report from Bristol based consultancy firm Eunomia has predicted that the UK’s rush to build incinerators will result in over capacity that will undermine recycling

Diesel cars responsible for 40 of NO2 air pollution in Bristol city centre

Diesel cars responsible for 40% of NO2 air pollution in Bristol city centre

Today Bristol City Council released a Cabinet Report on air quality that highlights the extent and concentration of air pollution across Bristol, with Nitrogen Dioxide levels recorded at twice the legal limit in some areas of the city centre. This follows months of work by Green councillors who passed a successful Full Council motion calling for action on clean air in November 2016.

Councillor Cleo Lake Avon Fire Authority statement

Councillor Cleo Lake: Avon Fire Authority statement

In her first statement as a new member, Councillor Cleo Lake addressed the recent events at Avon Fire Authority

Bristol Green Party guide to completing the Council consultations

Bristol Green Party guide to completing the Council consultations

The Council has several consultations running about proposed cuts to services including libraries, public toilets, services for people with learning disabilities and mental ill health, Neighbourhood Partnerships, and council tax relief for the very poorest households in the city.

Diesel generator in Bristol rejected due to air pollution concerns

Diesel generator in Bristol rejected due to air pollution concerns

A diesel generator planned for St Philips in Bristol has once again been rejected, this time on appeal. The decision comes after campaigning by local residents and months of campaigning by the local Green Party about the illegal and unsafe levels of air pollution in the city. The opposition to the proposed diesel power plant, which was to be built just a few hundred meters from a primary school, was a key component to the campaigns

Has Gove been reading Greens Agriculture and Brexit report

Has Gove been reading Green's Agriculture and Brexit report?

Molly, who sits on the European Parliament’s Agriculture Committee, has welcomed Michael Gove’s pledge to deliver a “Green Brexit”. She said: “It’s a moment to celebrate the extraordinary: Greens agree with Michael Gove. I’m left wondering if he has been reading the reports I commissioned on how we can create a more sustainable farming system?"

Green MEP calls on Bristols Labour MPs to back referendum on Brexit deal

Green MEP calls on Bristol's Labour MPs to back referendum on Brexit deal

Molly has called on the South West’s Labour MPs to back a ratification referendum on the final Brexit deal. The call comes following a recent survey which shows a majority of Labour members support the idea, and the increasingly vocal support for remaining in the EU from the region’s Labour MPs.

Green councillors question financial logic of cuts to tree maintenance

Green councillors question financial logic of cuts to tree maintenance

Green councillors highlight the hidden costs of cutting tree maintenance.

We use cookies on our website to improve your experience, by using our website you accept the use of these cookies. Read More Close