Bristol Green Party Logo

Tuesday, 4th Sep 2018

Green Group Leader: Mayor's arena decision shows contempt for democracy

The day after he voted for a council motion supporting a Temple Meads location for Bristol's Arena, the city's Labour Mayor has scrapped the project altogether in a Cabinet meeting.

During the debate in the extraordinary Full Council Meeting of Monday 3rd September, Greens and other councillors made the points that the Temple Meads arena was confirmed to be affordable by the KPMG reports that the Mayor commissioned, is deliverable within a few years and accessible to people from all parts of Bristol. They also raised numerous concerns if the project were to be abandoned by the Labour Mayor, including the risk of potential legal challenge and financial damages to the council, the lack of good alternative sites and likelihood that any alternative arena would not be deliverable due to planning and other obstacles.

The following is a statement on the decision taken at Cabinet of 4th September, by Green Group leader Councillor Eleanor Combley.

Mayor's arena decision shows contempt for democracy

After months of back and forth, this is what we know:

-          The temple quarter arena is affordable, can be delivered within 3 years, and it is the best location for an arena according to the Mayor and councillors. It would support city centre businesses and put Bristol on the map, as the Mayor himself said in 2012.

-          Thorough plans for alternative developments on that site do not exist – all we have at this stage are pretty drawings and a lot of hype from the private sector. L+G, the City’s supposed benefactors here, are currently fighting the council’s minimum affordable housing targets on a nearby site, proposing to build just 4 affordable homes out of 120. This shows just how unlikely it is that we can trust them to deliver affordable housing.

-          These alternative proposals could also be built in a number of locations around the city, while a city centre arena can only go ahead at the Temple Meads site.

-          Once this site is sold Bristol is unlikely to get any arena for many years – there are a serious number of legal, planning, and other issues in the way of a Filton location.

-          If an arena were eventually built at Filton it would create enormous congestion and transport problems in the north of the city and drain business from the city centre.

For the avoidance of all doubt, the motion passed in Full Council yesterday evening, which the Mayor voted for, reads:

"This Council believes that the best site for Bristol’s Arena, for the benefit of Bristol as a whole, is Temple Island in the centre of Bristol and that the decision taker should be guided by the vote at this meeting."

Most people reading those words would therefore have expected the Mayor to respect the democratic process, be guided by his councillors (and his own) votes and keep the Temple Quarter arena project instead of abandoning it for as-yet non-existent mixed development plans, gifting public land and assets to the private sector.

Unfortunately it is increasingly clear that this Mayor has complete contempt for democracy – whether it’s the manifesto pledge he was elected on to “complete the new city Arena and enable it to be accessible to all communities”, the votes of councillors, including his own, at two separate meetings, the views of 10 out of 11 of the chief scrutiny committee, or the popular opinion expressed through online polls, petitions, and hundreds of public statements submitted to council meetings – at the end of the day the only view that matters to Marvin Rees is his own. Leadership surely means listening to others and not being afraid to change your mind if the evidence points another way – yet instead of putting Bristol first the Mayor has spun every which way in trying to present a decision he took months ago in secret as fair and transparent, and quell disagreements within his own party. The most recent of these efforts was his attempt to reframe last night’s motion and vote as being about the best site ‘in an ideal world’ rather than in this world, to try and allow him to say one thing on Monday and do the complete opposite on Tuesday.

First the Temple Island arena was too expensive. Then an alternative project emerged to muddy the waters, owned by a company with links to many of the senior officers around the Mayor. Finally, after reports showed the Arena Island site to be both deliverable and affordable and the cost of the project shrank, it was deemed too risky, despite there being no evidence provided to support this. The Mayor seems to have got his economics mixed up with the Conservative government – at times of uncertainty we should be investing to support the city economy – we have seen on the national stage that austerity policies do not work.

Let’s be clear: at cabinet today the Mayor has betrayed the spirit of his vote yesterday and acted against the best interests of the city – putting short term savings before long term gain, putting the private sector over a publically owned arena, and abandoning his manifesto commitment to deliver an arena for Bristol by 2020.

Government threatens legal action against Bristol Mayor over poor air quality

Government threatens legal action against Bristol Mayor over poor air quality

Government threatens legal action against Bristol Mayor over inaction on poor air quality

Bristol Green councillor named politician of the year

Bristol Green councillor named politician of the year

Councillor Carla Denyer (Clifton Down) has been named politician of the year by The Big Green Political Podcast.

Green condemnation of death threats to mayor and deputy mayor

Green condemnation of death threats to mayor and deputy mayor

Westminster is now in gridlock says MEP after Brexit vote

"Westminster is now in gridlock" says MEP after Brexit vote

Responding to last night’s defeat for the government in the Brexit vote and today’s vote of confidence in the government, Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, said: “Westminster is now in gridlock. The failed leadership of Theresa May and weak or non-existent opposition from Labour’s front bench has brought us to a crisis; one which our politicians seem unable to resolve. That is why the only way forwards is to go back to the people.

Bristol Green Party welcome two city MPs supporting a Peoples Vote

Bristol Green Party welcome two city MPs supporting a People’s Vote

Senior Bristol Green Party representatives have today warmly welcomed Darren Jones MP and Kerry McCarthy MP’s publicly stated support for a 2nd Brexit referendum alongside 69 of their parliamentary colleagues but have expressed ‘bitter disappointment if not surprise’ that neither Thangam DebbonaireMP or Karin Smyth MP signed up to the call.

Labour wasting council time with attacks and selfcongratulatory cheerleading

Labour wasting council time with attacks and “self-congratulatory cheerleading”

At a Bristol Full Council meeting today, Green councillors criticised the Labour group for wasting valuable policy space with a 'self-congratulatory' motion, and tabled amendments to the motion which would have committed all councillors to protect valuable Council services in forthcoming budget.

BRISTOL GREENS CALL FOR A PEOPLES VOTE ON BREXIT

BRISTOL GREENS CALL FOR A PEOPLE’S VOTE ON BREXIT

BRISTOL GREENS CALL FOR A PEOPLE’S VOTE ON BREXIT

Corbyns Brexit stance leave Labour facing mass defections

Corbyn’s Brexit stance leave Labour facing mass defections

Commenting on Jeremy Corbyn’s speech, Molly Scott Cato, Green MEP for South West England and leading supporter of the People’s Vote campaign, said: “Theresa May is plainly not the only senior politician who has mastered the art of can kicking, as Jeremy Corbyn’s speech today avoided providing definitive answers to any of the major questions facing the country over Brexit.

Action needed for Bristol to be carbon neutral by 2030

Action needed for Bristol to be carbon neutral by 2030

Bristol’s Green Councillors have today launched a new report outlining the action needed for Bristol to meet its new commitment to becoming carbon neutral by 2030.

A Christmas message from Bristols Green mayoral candidate

A Christmas message from Bristol's Green mayoral candidate

A seasonal message from Sandy about how even when our national politics is so divided, we can unite as a city for our shared future.

Big news in the campaign to ban single use plastics

Big news in the campaign to ban single use plastics

Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has today welcomed tough new measures from the EU in banning some single use plastics

A Christmas message from Molly Scott Cato MEP

A Christmas message from Molly Scott Cato MEP

A Christmas message from Molly Scott Cato MEP on where we are on Brexit and how, as we head into 2019, a People's Vote offers a way out of our political crisis.

Green response to Theresa May winning no confidence vote

Green response to Theresa May winning no confidence vote

This is the response of Molly Scott Cato MEP, Bristol's Green MEP, to the announcement that Theresa May has won a no-confidence vote.

Council passes Green motion against cruel and inhumane immigration detention

Council passes Green motion against ‘cruel and inhumane’ immigration detention

Bristol City Councillors have supported calls for an end to immigration detention today, by adding their voice to the cities supporting the ‘These Walls Must Fall’ campaign.

Inspired by Bristol London Greens pass 2030 climate emergency Carbon Neutral motion

Inspired by Bristol, London Greens pass 2030 ‘climate emergency’ Carbon Neutral motion

After Greens in Bristol passed a motion to declare a Climate Emergency and move forward the city’s ‘carbon neutral’ target to 2030, London Assembly Greens have passed a similar motion challenging London Mayor Sadiq Khan to “set a precedent for other major and world cities” and commit to the same 2030 target.

Green MEP writes to Bristol MPs urging them to back a Peoples Vote

Green MEP writes to Bristol MPs urging them to back a People's Vote

Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has written to all 55 South West MPs urging them to reject Theresa May’s Brexit deal in next week’s crucial parliamentary vote. She has urged them to back a People’s Vote instead – effectively handing the decision on the country’s future back to voters.

End Immigration Detention  these walls must fall

End Immigration Detention - these walls must fall

Green Councillors have submitted a motion to a coming Full Council meeting (11 December) supporting calls for an end to immigration detention in the UK. The motion, proposed by Green councillor Fi Hance and seconded by Labour councillor Ruth Pickersgill, calls on Bristol’s Mayor to endorse the ‘These Walls Must Fall’ Campaign (1), lobby the UK government, and work with local MPs and other councils to push for changes in immigration law and alternatives to detention.(2)

Cuts still hitting the poorest despite Mayors warm words

Cuts still hitting the poorest despite Mayor’s warm words

Green Mayoral Candidate, Sandy Hore-Ruthven, has responded to the news that Bristol Mayor, Marvin Rees, has today joined a nationwide warning that ‘councils have reached breaking point’ over funding cuts

Greens demands for the COP24 negotiations

Greens demands for the COP24 negotiations

This December government leaders will gather in Katowice, Poland for the COP24 climate summit, where all countries of the world, including EU Member States, must commit to put forward higher 2030 climate targets by 2020. To stay below 1.5°C, as indicated in the landmark IPCC report, the EU needs to commit to significantly increase both its long-term and 2030 targets.

Bristol can become a beacon to the world on how to tackle climate change

Bristol can "become a beacon to the world on how to tackle climate change"

Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has said the South West region can become a beacon to the world on how to tackle climate change as well as showcasing the economic gains to be had from doing so. The region’s MEP has made the claim as negotiators from around the globe meet in Poland to discuss action on climate change and how to implement the 2015 Paris Agreement which aims to limit global warming to 1.5°C.

Bristols Green MEP challenges charitable status of rightwing think tanks

Bristol's Green MEP challenges charitable status of right-wing think tanks

Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has written to the Charity Commission to challenge the charitable status granted to a series of far-right think tanks. The challenge comes in the wake of the concession by one such organisation, the Taxpayers Alliance, that it had unfairly dismissed and smeared Brexit whistleblower Shahmir Sanni.

Buses are a right  not a privilege says Sandy HoreRuthven

Buses are a right – not a privilege, says Sandy Hore-Ruthven

A good bus service means people can get where they need to go, when they need to go. The ability to travel should not be based on your income or where you live.

Lack of affordable housing unacceptable

Lack of affordable housing unacceptable

Lack of affordable housing “completely unacceptable” – Green Councillor calls in Bedminster development plans

Its time for a Peoples Vote Bristols Green MEP responds to Withdrawal Agreement

"It's time for a People's Vote" Bristol's Green MEP responds to Withdrawal Agreement

People voted neither for no deal or a dodgy deal. It’s time for the real deal – a vote on the reality of Brexit compared with remaining in the EU. It’s time for a People’s Vote

Greens declare a Climate Emergency and bring Bristols CO2 emissions target forwards 20 years

Greens declare a Climate Emergency and bring Bristol’s CO2 emissions target forwards 20 years

A Green party motion calling on the Mayor of Bristol to declare a climate emergency and bring the city’s carbon neutrality target forward by 20 years (to 2030) passed in a Full Council meeting this evening, committing Bristol to the most ambitious climate change target out of all UK Core Cities.

Greens challenge Mayor on support for Tall Buildings

Greens challenge Mayor on support for Tall Buildings

Green councillors have raised concerns about the Labour Mayor’s support for high rise buildings

Greens call on Mayor declare a Climate Emergency

Greens call on Mayor: declare a Climate Emergency

Green councillors in Bristol are calling on the city’s Mayor to declare a Climate Emergency and bring forward Bristol’s carbon neutrality target, in a motion submitted to Full Council next week.

Time to kick plastic addiction as Green petition to be debated by Council

Time to kick plastic addiction as Green petition to be debated by Council

Thousands of people across Bristol have signed a petition to get rid of unnecessary disposable plastics started by Green Councillor Martin Fodor. The petition has received so much support that it will be debated by all councillors at Full Council. It will also receive a response from the Mayor. The petition calls on the Mayor to take all practical steps to eliminating wasteful plastic across Bristol and has been supported by plastics campaigners across the city. Greens have been campaigning for Bristol to become single-use plastic free for many years, tabling a motion on this in both 2015 and 2016.

Green response to 2018 budget

Green response to 2018 budget

Responding to the 2018 budget, Bristol's Green MEP and party finance spokesperson, Molly Scott Cato MEP, said: “Greens said that this must be an emergency budget for the climate and that it would fail if a single pound was spent on climate wrecking projects [1].

Response to Mayors State of the City speech

Response to Mayor's 'State of the City' speech

Bristol's Green Mayoral Candidate responds to the Labour Mayor's unambitious 'State of the City' annual speech.

We use cookies on our website to improve your experience, by using our website you accept the use of these cookies. Read More Close