Below is a statement from Green Group Leader Eleanor Combley, submitted to the Cabinet meeting of July 3rd. Councillor Combley supports the work of the Council’s Scrutiny committee and calls on the Mayor to go beyond the narrow scope of his KPMG reports, which don’t adhere to government guidelines, and be transparent about what criteria are being used to make his decision.
In his blog the Mayor suggested that 70% of visitors to arenas drive – but this is not a fixed figure and depends entirely on the arena location – for example at Manchester arena, also located by a train station, this figure is just 39%.
The report from Scrutiny (OSM) to Cabinet is attached below Cllr Combley's statement and the key conclusions have been pulled out for reference.
Cllr Eleanor Combley, Statement on Cabinet Agenda Item 6 – Reports from scrutiny commission
I would like to thank all the other councillors, from all parties, who contributed to this process by submitting questions and statements, and the members of the public, who despite the very short notice, managed to do likewise. Most of all, I think we should all be thanking the members of OSMB who went through the reports with a fine-toothed comb and were rigorous in their questioning of all aspects. They broke open the black box of the numbers and as a result brought information into the public debate that had not really seen the light of day before. I highlight a number of our key observations from the reports and the associated process.
- Greens note that ten out of eleven members of OSMB agreed on the substantive issue that Temple Island is the only viable option for Bristol’s arena.
- During the Scrutiny process KPMG and council officers confirmed that building the Arena at Arena Island would not impact on the Council’s revenue budget and that there is no funding gap. Building the arena there represents reasonable value, justifies public investment and will not impact on the council wider finances.
- Greens formally requested in January that the administration share the terms of reference for KPMG’s proposed reports. In spite of a repeated request in March by the Greens these terms of reference were not shared before the reports had been written. Consequently the terms of reference for the reports were inadequately narrow.
- In June 2018 KPMG received a £3.2m fine from the Financial Reporting Council for among other things ‘Failure to exercise sufficient professional scepticism’ with its customer. Although KPMG have been explicit in warning of the preliminary and incomplete nature of some of the information they were given to work with, Greens are still not sure that there has been enough appropriate professional judgement in its work for Bristol City Council on the arena location:
- It has taken at face value YTL’s unsubstantiated commercial forecasts.
- It has undervalued future assets relating to Arena Island. Importantly the multi-storey car park with a £16m build cost is forecast to have no value in 25 years’ time.
- It has accepted at face value Colin Molton’s forecast that BCC will spend £34m on its side of supervising someone else building the arena.
- KPMG has failed to follow the advice in HM Treasury Green Book guidance relating to sensitivity analysis. This would have meant that a range of possible values (for value added, for costs etc) would have been generated which would have been much more appropriate given the uncertainties and apparent optimism bias of many of the numbers.
- In spite of HM Treasury Green Book guidance, KPMG has not adequately taken into account social, cultural, environmental, broader economic and risk issues which could then form the basis for appropriate decision making. Regardless of whether the responsibility for this lies with KPMG for exercising a lack of appropriate professional scepticism or with the administration for failing to develop adequate terms of reference, the end result is a report that is of only limited usefulness in the city’s decision making process.
- In the absence of any systematic decision making criteria for the location of the arena Greens have called on the Mayor to be explicit about what should be these decision making criteria.
- Greens have proposed a set of decision making criteria on the location of the arena, which they have shared with the Mayor. These criteria are broadly in line with HM Treasury’s Green Book guidance on the evaluation of public sector projects and these criteria can be refined. The Mayor has not responded to these proposed criteria and we would welcome feedback.
- The Mayor has drawn attention to the carbon footprint of the arena, which I would certainly agree should form part of those criteria. It is worth noting that almost 60% of emissions associated with arenas are due to audience members travelling by car. The mayor and officers have quoted a figure of 70% of audience members traveling by car, however it does not have to be that way. Manchester has a city centre arena right next to Victoria Station, and less than 40% of its audience come by car. Getting the site right, and giving audience members the options of using public transport, walking or cycling, can massively reduce that carbon footprint.
The future is not a destination, it is something we imagine, plan and build, and this decision is one with real impact for the shape of our future, so thanks again to everyone who has so far contributed to, hopefully, getting the best possible decision for Bristol.
Key conclusions from the OSM board’s report to Cabinet (Full report: OSM_arena_VFM_report.pdf)
“It is the considered view of OSM members that;
• The existing Arena figures are cautious
• The Brabazon Arena figures are optimistic
• Insufficient attention had been paid to social value in concentrating purely on value for money
• Environmental impact has been ignored in terms of the Filton proposal
• An arena for all of Bristol requires accessibility for all and that case is not proven at Filton
• The Arena Island proposal is close to being “shovel ready”
• The needs for planning, traffic planning and infrastructure at Filton mean the time line is much longer than the Temple Meads proposal
• It is disappointing that the only invitee who did not accept our invitation is the Mayor of Bristol. I urge the Mayor to meet with the OSM party leads to discuss our report before concluding his decision
• The sale of the land for the university campus at Temple Meads has damaged the economic case for the Arena. The site is now smaller and there is reduced opportunity to boost the economy of the area, part of which forms one of Bristol’s most deprived wards.
• Members were encouraged by YTL’s vision for the Filton site, however, there were many details still to be confirmed as the scheme is only at an outline stage. In particular the major caveats in relation to planning permission (the sequential test) and the delivery of essential transport infrastructure.
• The delayed publication of Value for Money reports created unnecessary pressures on officers and scrutiny to complete their work
• There is little or no time for the Mayor to take note of the views of scrutiny before his decision is published on Monday”
School climate strike children’s brave stand has our support
We are inspired that our children, spurred on by the noble actions of Greta Thunberg and other striking students, are making their voices heard, say 224 academics
"Voices of young people must be heard"
Green councillors have called for Bristol’s Mayor, Bristol City Council and local teachers and parents to support those students choosing to join this Friday’s school strike on climate change. On Friday 15th February, school children from across Bristol will be taking part in the first nationwide ‘Youth Strike 4 Climate’ inspired by the actions of 16 year old Greta Thunberg in Sweden. This Friday, many of Bristol’s schoolchildren will be joining the 70,000 schoolchildren from 270 cities and towns across the world who have been taking part in ‘Fridays for Future’ demanding that politicians take action to confront the climate emergency.
Mayor must end support of airport expansion
"How can Mayor Marvin Rees unequivocally support the expansion of Bristol Airport (BBC Sunday Politics 3rd February), when he has voted for a Green plan to make Bristol carbon neutral by 2030 and has tasked council officers to explore how to achieve this aim. Their report won’t be due until May, so on what evidence is he making this decision?
Bristol's Green Lord Mayor to save money, cut pollution with new hybrid car
Green Lord Mayor of Bristol, Cllr Cleo Lake, has a new hybrid car for her Mayoral vehicle after the expiry of the lease on the previous diesel vehicle
Bristol Council buys new home for children in care thanks to Green budget amendment
An item coming to Bristol Council Cabinet today approved the purchase of a home for children in care, putting a budget amendment introduced by Green Group leader Councillor Eleanor Combley into practice.
Last chance to have your say on “reckless” airport expansion
There is one week left to respond to a public consultation on Bristol Airport’s expansion plans, which closes on 26 January
Government threatens legal action against Bristol Mayor over poor air quality
Government threatens legal action against Bristol Mayor over inaction on poor air quality
Bristol Green councillor named politician of the year
Councillor Carla Denyer (Clifton Down) has been named politician of the year by The Big Green Political Podcast.
Green condemnation of death threats to mayor and deputy mayor
"Westminster is now in gridlock" says MEP after Brexit vote
Responding to last night’s defeat for the government in the Brexit vote and today’s vote of confidence in the government, Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, said: “Westminster is now in gridlock. The failed leadership of Theresa May and weak or non-existent opposition from Labour’s front bench has brought us to a crisis; one which our politicians seem unable to resolve. That is why the only way forwards is to go back to the people.
Bristol Green Party welcome two city MPs supporting a People’s Vote
Senior Bristol Green Party representatives have today warmly welcomed Darren Jones MP and Kerry McCarthy MP’s publicly stated support for a 2nd Brexit referendum alongside 69 of their parliamentary colleagues but have expressed ‘bitter disappointment if not surprise’ that neither Thangam DebbonaireMP or Karin Smyth MP signed up to the call.
Labour wasting council time with attacks and “self-congratulatory cheerleading”
At a Bristol Full Council meeting today, Green councillors criticised the Labour group for wasting valuable policy space with a 'self-congratulatory' motion, and tabled amendments to the motion which would have committed all councillors to protect valuable Council services in forthcoming budget.
BRISTOL GREENS CALL FOR A PEOPLE’S VOTE ON BREXIT
BRISTOL GREENS CALL FOR A PEOPLE’S VOTE ON BREXIT
Corbyn’s Brexit stance leave Labour facing mass defections
Commenting on Jeremy Corbyn’s speech, Molly Scott Cato, Green MEP for South West England and leading supporter of the People’s Vote campaign, said: “Theresa May is plainly not the only senior politician who has mastered the art of can kicking, as Jeremy Corbyn’s speech today avoided providing definitive answers to any of the major questions facing the country over Brexit.
Action needed for Bristol to be carbon neutral by 2030
Bristol’s Green Councillors have today launched a new report outlining the action needed for Bristol to meet its new commitment to becoming carbon neutral by 2030.
A Christmas message from Bristol's Green mayoral candidate
A seasonal message from Sandy about how even when our national politics is so divided, we can unite as a city for our shared future.
Big news in the campaign to ban single use plastics
Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has today welcomed tough new measures from the EU in banning some single use plastics
A Christmas message from Molly Scott Cato MEP
A Christmas message from Molly Scott Cato MEP on where we are on Brexit and how, as we head into 2019, a People's Vote offers a way out of our political crisis.
Green response to Theresa May winning no confidence vote
This is the response of Molly Scott Cato MEP, Bristol's Green MEP, to the announcement that Theresa May has won a no-confidence vote.
Council passes Green motion against ‘cruel and inhumane’ immigration detention
Bristol City Councillors have supported calls for an end to immigration detention today, by adding their voice to the cities supporting the ‘These Walls Must Fall’ campaign.
Inspired by Bristol, London Greens pass 2030 ‘climate emergency’ Carbon Neutral motion
After Greens in Bristol passed a motion to declare a Climate Emergency and move forward the city’s ‘carbon neutral’ target to 2030, London Assembly Greens have passed a similar motion challenging London Mayor Sadiq Khan to “set a precedent for other major and world cities” and commit to the same 2030 target.
Green MEP writes to Bristol MPs urging them to back a People's Vote
Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has written to all 55 South West MPs urging them to reject Theresa May’s Brexit deal in next week’s crucial parliamentary vote. She has urged them to back a People’s Vote instead – effectively handing the decision on the country’s future back to voters.
End Immigration Detention - these walls must fall
Green Councillors have submitted a motion to a coming Full Council meeting (11 December) supporting calls for an end to immigration detention in the UK. The motion, proposed by Green councillor Fi Hance and seconded by Labour councillor Ruth Pickersgill, calls on Bristol’s Mayor to endorse the ‘These Walls Must Fall’ Campaign (1), lobby the UK government, and work with local MPs and other councils to push for changes in immigration law and alternatives to detention.(2)
Cuts still hitting the poorest despite Mayor’s warm words
Green Mayoral Candidate, Sandy Hore-Ruthven, has responded to the news that Bristol Mayor, Marvin Rees, has today joined a nationwide warning that ‘councils have reached breaking point’ over funding cuts
Greens demands for the COP24 negotiations
This December government leaders will gather in Katowice, Poland for the COP24 climate summit, where all countries of the world, including EU Member States, must commit to put forward higher 2030 climate targets by 2020. To stay below 1.5°C, as indicated in the landmark IPCC report, the EU needs to commit to significantly increase both its long-term and 2030 targets.
Bristol can "become a beacon to the world on how to tackle climate change"
Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has said the South West region can become a beacon to the world on how to tackle climate change as well as showcasing the economic gains to be had from doing so. The region’s MEP has made the claim as negotiators from around the globe meet in Poland to discuss action on climate change and how to implement the 2015 Paris Agreement which aims to limit global warming to 1.5°C.
Bristol's Green MEP challenges charitable status of right-wing think tanks
Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has written to the Charity Commission to challenge the charitable status granted to a series of far-right think tanks. The challenge comes in the wake of the concession by one such organisation, the Taxpayers Alliance, that it had unfairly dismissed and smeared Brexit whistleblower Shahmir Sanni.
Buses are a right – not a privilege, says Sandy Hore-Ruthven
A good bus service means people can get where they need to go, when they need to go. The ability to travel should not be based on your income or where you live.
Lack of affordable housing unacceptable
Lack of affordable housing “completely unacceptable” – Green Councillor calls in Bedminster development plans
"It's time for a People's Vote" Bristol's Green MEP responds to Withdrawal Agreement
People voted neither for no deal or a dodgy deal. It’s time for the real deal – a vote on the reality of Brexit compared with remaining in the EU. It’s time for a People’s Vote