Below is a statement from Green Group Leader Eleanor Combley, submitted to the Cabinet meeting of July 3rd. Councillor Combley supports the work of the Council’s Scrutiny committee and calls on the Mayor to go beyond the narrow scope of his KPMG reports, which don’t adhere to government guidelines, and be transparent about what criteria are being used to make his decision.
In his blog the Mayor suggested that 70% of visitors to arenas drive – but this is not a fixed figure and depends entirely on the arena location – for example at Manchester arena, also located by a train station, this figure is just 39%.
The report from Scrutiny (OSM) to Cabinet is attached below Cllr Combley's statement and the key conclusions have been pulled out for reference.
Cllr Eleanor Combley, Statement on Cabinet Agenda Item 6 – Reports from scrutiny commission
I would like to thank all the other councillors, from all parties, who contributed to this process by submitting questions and statements, and the members of the public, who despite the very short notice, managed to do likewise. Most of all, I think we should all be thanking the members of OSMB who went through the reports with a fine-toothed comb and were rigorous in their questioning of all aspects. They broke open the black box of the numbers and as a result brought information into the public debate that had not really seen the light of day before. I highlight a number of our key observations from the reports and the associated process.
- Greens note that ten out of eleven members of OSMB agreed on the substantive issue that Temple Island is the only viable option for Bristol’s arena.
- During the Scrutiny process KPMG and council officers confirmed that building the Arena at Arena Island would not impact on the Council’s revenue budget and that there is no funding gap. Building the arena there represents reasonable value, justifies public investment and will not impact on the council wider finances.
- Greens formally requested in January that the administration share the terms of reference for KPMG’s proposed reports. In spite of a repeated request in March by the Greens these terms of reference were not shared before the reports had been written. Consequently the terms of reference for the reports were inadequately narrow.
- In June 2018 KPMG received a £3.2m fine from the Financial Reporting Council for among other things ‘Failure to exercise sufficient professional scepticism’ with its customer. Although KPMG have been explicit in warning of the preliminary and incomplete nature of some of the information they were given to work with, Greens are still not sure that there has been enough appropriate professional judgement in its work for Bristol City Council on the arena location:
- It has taken at face value YTL’s unsubstantiated commercial forecasts.
- It has undervalued future assets relating to Arena Island. Importantly the multi-storey car park with a £16m build cost is forecast to have no value in 25 years’ time.
- It has accepted at face value Colin Molton’s forecast that BCC will spend £34m on its side of supervising someone else building the arena.
- KPMG has failed to follow the advice in HM Treasury Green Book guidance relating to sensitivity analysis. This would have meant that a range of possible values (for value added, for costs etc) would have been generated which would have been much more appropriate given the uncertainties and apparent optimism bias of many of the numbers.
- In spite of HM Treasury Green Book guidance, KPMG has not adequately taken into account social, cultural, environmental, broader economic and risk issues which could then form the basis for appropriate decision making. Regardless of whether the responsibility for this lies with KPMG for exercising a lack of appropriate professional scepticism or with the administration for failing to develop adequate terms of reference, the end result is a report that is of only limited usefulness in the city’s decision making process.
- In the absence of any systematic decision making criteria for the location of the arena Greens have called on the Mayor to be explicit about what should be these decision making criteria.
- Greens have proposed a set of decision making criteria on the location of the arena, which they have shared with the Mayor. These criteria are broadly in line with HM Treasury’s Green Book guidance on the evaluation of public sector projects and these criteria can be refined. The Mayor has not responded to these proposed criteria and we would welcome feedback.
- The Mayor has drawn attention to the carbon footprint of the arena, which I would certainly agree should form part of those criteria. It is worth noting that almost 60% of emissions associated with arenas are due to audience members travelling by car. The mayor and officers have quoted a figure of 70% of audience members traveling by car, however it does not have to be that way. Manchester has a city centre arena right next to Victoria Station, and less than 40% of its audience come by car. Getting the site right, and giving audience members the options of using public transport, walking or cycling, can massively reduce that carbon footprint.
The future is not a destination, it is something we imagine, plan and build, and this decision is one with real impact for the shape of our future, so thanks again to everyone who has so far contributed to, hopefully, getting the best possible decision for Bristol.
Key conclusions from the OSM board’s report to Cabinet (Full report: OSM_arena_VFM_report.pdf)
“It is the considered view of OSM members that;
• The existing Arena figures are cautious
• The Brabazon Arena figures are optimistic
• Insufficient attention had been paid to social value in concentrating purely on value for money
• Environmental impact has been ignored in terms of the Filton proposal
• An arena for all of Bristol requires accessibility for all and that case is not proven at Filton
• The Arena Island proposal is close to being “shovel ready”
• The needs for planning, traffic planning and infrastructure at Filton mean the time line is much longer than the Temple Meads proposal
• It is disappointing that the only invitee who did not accept our invitation is the Mayor of Bristol. I urge the Mayor to meet with the OSM party leads to discuss our report before concluding his decision
• The sale of the land for the university campus at Temple Meads has damaged the economic case for the Arena. The site is now smaller and there is reduced opportunity to boost the economy of the area, part of which forms one of Bristol’s most deprived wards.
• Members were encouraged by YTL’s vision for the Filton site, however, there were many details still to be confirmed as the scheme is only at an outline stage. In particular the major caveats in relation to planning permission (the sequential test) and the delivery of essential transport infrastructure.
• The delayed publication of Value for Money reports created unnecessary pressures on officers and scrutiny to complete their work
• There is little or no time for the Mayor to take note of the views of scrutiny before his decision is published on Monday”
Bristol shoppers join worldwide campaign returning unnecessary plastic to supermarkets
This weekend Bristol shoppers and Greens joined campaigners from around the world in ‘plastic attacks’ to hand back their unneeded single use plastics to supermarkets across Bristol.
Letter: Bristol Cllrs must vote against the proposed airport expansion
We can all do our bit to help reduce the impact of climate change by choosing to walk and cycle more or fly less, but only politicians can make the big decisions that will decide whether our planet blossoms or burns. It is time they start treating climate change as the global emergency that it is.
Arena decision: Why are we letting austerity dictate how our city should grow?
You can’t shrink to greatness! But with the arena decision at cabinet last week that is what it feels like Bristol has done.
Bristol Greens to attend #RiseForClimate rally in Bristol – 8th September
Alongside organisations in Bristol and in cities around the world, Bristol Green Party members and elected representatives will be demanding urgent action on climate change by taking part in the #RiseForClimate rally in Bristol on 8th September.
Green Group Leader: Mayor's arena decision shows contempt for democracy
The day after he voted for a council motion supporting a Temple Meads location for Bristol's Arena, the city's Labour Mayor has scrapped the project altogether in a Cabinet meeting.
Opinion: Bristol wants the arena on Arena Island
Bristol Green Party's Deputy Coordinator writes for 24/7 about why the Mayor should listen and build the Arena on Arena Island.
Mayor should ‘abide by’ council vote for Arena location
A majority of cross-party councillors have taken the unusual step of calling an extraordinary Council meeting to vote on the location of Bristol’s Arena, and demanding that the Mayor ‘abides by’ the decision made. The Arena’s future was due to be decided by the Mayor on Sept 4th. However, amid growing accusations that the Mayor’s decision may be biased (1), councillors have called for a free vote. The letter to the Mayor includes signatures from a majority of councillors, including signatures from all four political parties.
Listen Again to Molly Scott Cato's speech at Bristol's People's Vote rally
Why Arena island is still the best location for Bristol's Arena
The Mayor’s own Value for Money study showed that the arena will pay for itself, will add no burden to the public purse, will not impact on council services and will leave the city with a significant asset. The Mayor has acknowledged on a number of occasions, and most recently on BBC Points West last Thursday, that an arena at Temple Island would be affordable for the city.
£5m cuts to special needs budget 'hidden' from Council
Bristol’s cabinet member for education and skills has been accused of misleading the council by hiding concerns around £5m of cuts to a special needs budget. A High Court judge has ruled that Bristol City Council did not properly consult over the cuts to the high needs block. Clive Stevens, Green councillor for Clifton Down, said: “It’s important that lessons are learned. The 2016 Bundred Review highlighted the need for councillors to be given clear information, but here in 2018 we had a £5m cut which was simply not shown in the budget papers." For the full article please see here>>
Checking the numbers on alternatives to the Bristol Arena
'Bristol deserves better than this' - Deputy group leader Jerome Thomas has a look at the numbers supporting the 'alternative development' at Temple Meads in place of an arena.
Green MEP to join People’s March rally in Bristol this Saturday
Green MEP for the South West and former Bristol West parliamentary candidate, Molly Scott Cato, will join a cross-party group of politicians and campaign groups at a rally in Bristol this Saturday calling for a People’s Vote on the final Brexit deal
Enough talk, time for action on plastics waste
Following the reports of huge amounts of unrecycled plastic waste left on the streets after St Paul’s Carnival, Greens are calling for the Council to make sure that lessons are learnt ahead of this weekend’s balloon festival. Green councillors also want Bristol Council to stop dragging its heels and implement a policy on plastics waste as soon as possible, including a ban on single-use plastics at council events.
Greens discuss arena, libraries, and racism on politics podcast
Catch up on the Green appearances on Bristol Live's local politics podcast.
Remove abandoned billboards that blight our city
A local Green councillor for Clifton Down in Bristol has successfully applied for an unsightly abandoned billboard on Whiteladies Road to be removed.
BBC must refuse airtime to organisations lacking funding transparency
In the wake of revelations that right-wing think tank, the Institute for Economic Affairs (IEA), offered potential US donors “cash for access” to Conservative ministers, Bristol's Green MEP Molly Scott Cato has launched a petition calling on the BBC to stop giving airtime to organisations whose funding is not transparent.
Help protect 20mph limits around your home
Press Release: “Help protect 20mph limits around your home” say Green Councillors
Bristol can’t wait decades for action on climate change
Following the hottest day so far this year, Bristol Green Councillors are calling for Bristol to take a leading role in tackling climate change, with clear action needed now if the city is to meet its carbon targets.
Why we need to preserve our 20mph city
The Green Party believes it is vital that we retain the 20mph limits in the city which have brought such benefits for huge areas of the city as a whole. 20mph is good for our safety, our environment and our health.
Exposing the ‘Mafia-like’ organisations behind Brexit
After Jacob Rees-Mogg accused the EU of acting like the Mafia, the criticism is reflected back on him by evidence gathered together in a new website called The Brexit Syndicate, which is launched today by Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato.
We need a 'People's Vote' on Brexit deal
Personally I feel very strongly about my rights as a European being taken away. My entire heritage is elsewhere in Europe and losing the right to visit, live or work across the travel area with my EU passport is distressing.
Group leader responds to the Mayor's Annual Speech
"We’ve heard a lot of beautiful words today, we keep hearing a lot of beautiful words, but the gulf between those words and the reality of the actions I see, and what people around me experience, is so huge that I can’t be silent"
Dangerous parking is putting people’s lives at risk
Green councillors are calling for urgent action to help communities who are suffering with dangerous parking problems, particularly in areas adjoining resident parking zones across the City. Greens have tabled a motion to the Full Council meeting taking place on Tuesday 17th July to urge the Mayor to make sure that communities have access to the support they need to sort out these local parking problems.
How can a Labour Mayor support airport expansion for the few, not the many?
In light of a new analysis showing that airport expansion disproportionally benefits the wealthiest in society, Green councillor Carla Denyer will ask Bristol’s Mayor to reconcile his contradictory views about climate change and airport expansion.
Greens call for ban on balloon releases
From Bristol 24/7: "Fresh calls have been made to introduce a city-wide ban on people releasing balloons or sky lanterns across Bristol."
Bristol Airport carbon targets worthless without roadmap, say Greens
Days before Bristol Airport’s consultation closes, a Green Party councillor has revealed that the Airport has no plan in place for delivering on its carbon goals.
Greens to Mayor: listen to Scrutiny on the Arena
"The future is not a destination, it is something we imagine, plan and build, and this decision is one with real impact for the shape of our future"
Bristol's MEP slams Tories & Labour over ‘climate wrecking’ decisions
Molly has condemned the government for its decision not to back the world’s first tidal power lagoon at Swansea Bay but, on the same day, give the green light to expand Heathrow airport.
Bristol Greens invite Labour MPs to oppose Heathrow expansion
Bristol Green Party are today inviting the city's Labour MPs to join them in a united opposition to the expansion of Heathrow Airport that would "smash" the UK's climate change efforts. The invite comes after Bristol North West MP Darren Jones tweeted his intention to abstain, stating "it doesn’t significantly impact Bristol, so I’ll be abstaining" despite an election commitment to local Green party supporters to meet with Bristol Green Party regularly to discuss environmental issues.
Everything falling into place for Arena Island
Green Councillors are delighted that the last week of scrutiny has demonstrated the case for an Arena in the central of Bristol.