Bristol Green Party Logo

Tuesday, 6th Mar 2018

High Court refuses MEP's Brexit case

The High Court has this morning refused permission for judicial review to compel the government to release its Brexit impact studies. Molly Scott Cato MEP and Jolyon Maugham QC of the Good Law Project have been pressing for the release of impact studies on 58 sectors of the economy and a report prepared by HM Treasury, comparing the predicted economic detriment of Brexit with the potential benefits of alternative free trade arrangements [1].

Molly and Mr Maugham argued at today’s hearing that full public release of the studies are “of very considerable importance in informing public debate about the current negotiations regarding the UK’s proposed departure from the European Union [2].” However, the High Court judge, Justice Supperstone, argued that an adequate alternative remedy exists, namely through Freedom of Information (FoI) requests.

Responding to the verdict, Molly said:

“This is incredibly disappointing. So many attempts to release these studies through Freedom of Information requests have already been attempted and refused. British people are being denied access to evidence about the impact of Brexit on their lives.

“Rightly, for any major infrastructure scheme like a new road or runway, a publicly available impact study is taken as read. But apparently, it’s OK to drag a nation through one of the biggest changes in our lifetimes without allowing people to understand the consequences.

“Today’s verdict gives the government a green light to continue hiding these studies on the economic impacts of Brexit from the public. The Buzzfeed leak a few weeks ago did reveal  – in part at least – some of the impact assessments we had been requesting. But this information has not, of course, been made fully available to the public. The leak also showed why the government is so keen to keep a lid on this information. It revealed that in every possible Brexit scenario the UK will be worse off economically that it would be if it remained a member of the EU.”

Notes

[1] See previous releases, letters and articles relating to the Brexit impact studies here:

[2] See Claimants Grounds for Seeking Reconsideration

Pie in the sky  Green Group responds to release of Mayors value for money arena reports

'Pie in the sky' - Green Group responds to release of Mayor's 'value for money' arena reports

"What was first touted as a simple ‘value for money’ review is beginning to look like a very expensive piece of political justification for a decision it seems the Mayor has already taken in private..."

Bristol Greens urge local MPs to back important vote on staying in the Single Market

Bristol Greens urge local MPs to back important vote on staying in the Single Market

Bristol Green Councillors have today jointly written to the four Bristol MPs urging them to “support the Lords’ amendment to find an EEA-style solution to the Brexit problem”

Brexit update from Bristols Green MEP

Brexit update from Bristol's Green MEP

Brexit update from Bristol's Green MEP Molly Scott Cato

Green Lord Mayor Cleo Lakes acceptance speech

Green Lord Mayor Cleo Lake's acceptance speech

Full text of the acceptance speech by Bristol's new Lord Mayor

Bedminster Green survey  locals reject tall buildings

Bedminster Green survey - locals reject tall buildings

Southville Green councillors Charlie Bolton and Steve Clarke have conducted a survey of local residents to explore their views on the proposals by a set of developers to construct over 1200 new homes in the Bedminster Green area.

Cleo Lake becomes Lord Mayor

Cleo Lake becomes Lord Mayor

Green Councillor Cleo Lake took up her role as Lord Mayor of Bristol to applause from a packed puiblic chamber where friends, family and members of the local communty had come to see her take up the position of first citizen of Bristol this week.

Watch Bristols MEP makes the case for a Peoples Vote on Brexit

Watch: Bristol's MEP makes the case for a 'People's Vote' on Brexit

Molly talks to BBC Sunday Politics South West about the importance of a People’s Vote on the final Brexit deal, especially for students and young people who were unable to vote in the EU referendum.

Job Junior Constituency Assistant  Bristol Office of Molly Scott Cato MEP

Job: Junior Constituency Assistant – Bristol Office of Molly Scott Cato MEP

Molly is looking for a part time (21 hours per week) Junior Constituency Assistant for her constituency office in Bristol. The role will start in approximately July 2018 and will initially be for a fixed term period of 3 months.

Bristols MEP condemns Not me Gove strategy for air pollution

Bristol's MEP condemns ‘Not me Gove’ ‘strategy’ for air pollution

Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato has accused Environment Secretary Michael Gove of pointing the finger of blame for the UK’s illegal air quality in every direction but at the government and the chief causes of the problem.

Greens call for Bristol West MP to push for continued single market membership

Greens call for Bristol West MP to push for continued single market membership

Molly Scott Cato, Bristol's Green MEP, has called on Bristol West MP, Thangam Debbonaire, to use the ‘ray of hope’ offered by the Lords yesterday and vote to keep the UK inside the single market.

Why did the Council drop Bristol Energy

Why did the Council drop Bristol Energy?

Did LeaveEU take data from Bristol companies

Did Leave.EU take data from Bristol companies?

Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has today written to Avon and Somerset Police to ask if the force is investigating new evidence that Bristol companies GoSkippy and Eldon Insurance allegedly shared data illegally with Leave.EU.

Green councillors stand with Friends of Redland Library against closure

Green councillors stand with Friends of Redland Library against closure

At a meeting of Friends of Redland Library last week, Green councillors Carla Denyer and Clive Stevens were amongst the speakers updating residents about the progress of the campaign to save Bristol’s libraries.

Brexit update from Bristols Green MEP

Brexit update from Bristol's Green MEP

An update from Molly Scott Cato, Bristol's Green MEP and the national EU spokesperson

Keeping Bristols parks adfree

Keeping Bristol’s parks ad-free

At a council meeting on March 20 Bristol Council debated a petition to ‘Keep our parks advertising free’, in response to the Labour administration’s proposals to introduce commercial advertising to Bristol's parks and green spaces. Green Cllr Steve Clarke spoke in response.

Bristol Uni announces it will become fossil free

Bristol Uni announces it will become fossil free

The University of Bristol, after extensive talks, announced today that it will withdraw all £700,000 of its investment from the fossil fuel industry. Moving from partial to full divestment is a big step forward for the university, with plans being put in place to ditch all fossil fuel companies from its investment portfolio over the next couple of years.

Council votes for Temple Meads arena location after Green motion

Council votes for Temple Meads arena location after Green motion

Over five thousand people have now signed a petition calling for the Mayor to support a Bristol arena at Temple Meads. Green councillors brought the matter to a vote with a motion to Full Council.

Its time for a drug consumption room in Bristol

It’s time for a drug consumption room in Bristol

Green Councillor Cleo Lake is calling for Bristol to launch a drug consumption room to give drug users a safer space with access to needles and specialist support.

Bristols Three ProEU MEPs release joint statement on Russian poison attack

Bristol's Three Pro-EU MEPs release joint statement on Russian poison attack

“In a difficult week for pro-EU MEPs, when we debated the next stage of the leaving process, it was heartening to feel the warmth and generosity of our European colleagues in solidarity with the UK in the face of Russian aggression."

Greens bring vote on Arena location to Council meeting

Greens bring vote on Arena location to Council meeting

Green Councillors have secured a Council debate and vote on the location of Bristol’s arena at next Tuesday’s Council meeting.

Bristols next Lord Mayor announced as Green Councillor Cleo Lake

Bristol’s next Lord Mayor announced as Green Councillor Cleo Lake

Green Councillors have announced their candidate for Lord Mayor as Cotham Councillor, Cleo Lake

Clean Air Action Plan proposed after years of Green campaigning

Clean Air Action Plan proposed after years of Green campaigning

At Bristol Council today, the Cabinet approved the development of a Clean Air Action Plan to tackle the illegal levels of air pollution in the city, which has been estimated to contribute to over 300 premature deaths per year.

High Court refuses MEPs Brexit case

High Court refuses MEP's Brexit case

High Court refuses to force government’s hand over Brexit impact studies

Bristols MEP is today in High Court over Brexit court action

Bristol's MEP is today in High Court over Brexit court action

The High Court will this morning hear an oral application for permission to apply for judicial review to compel the production, in public, of the studies the government continues to withhold on the economic impacts of Brexit.

Green Group leader lobbies Treasury for end to local government cuts

Green Group leader lobbies Treasury for end to local government cuts

Green Group leader Eleanor Combley today travelled to London to hand in a letter to the Treasury calling for an end to cuts to local government funding.

Greens refuse to vote for Labours cuts budget

Greens refuse to vote for Labour’s cuts budget

At today’s budget Full Council meeting in Bristol City Hall, the city’s Green Councillors have refused to vote for the Labour Mayor’s austerity budget that proposed cuts of £34 million across Bristol, including library and public toilet closures and a large funding cut to Adult Social Care.

Raft of Green amendments passes at Budget Full Council

Raft of Green amendments passes at Budget Full Council

Bristol’s Green Councillors are celebrating today as all but one of their budget amendments at today’s Budget Full Council were passed.

Plot to ditch EU food standards threatens South West producers

Plot to ditch EU food standards threatens South West producers

Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has warned of a plot by leading rightwing Brexiteers to ditch EU food and safety standards that would allow the import of US meats, drugs and chemicals currently banned in Britain.

New report on Britains broken housing market  lessons from other EU Countries

New report on ‘Britain’s broken housing market’ & lessons from other EU Countries

Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has launched a report she commissioned on the UK’s housing crisis.

Opinion Blue sky thinking not allowed  frustrations of Bristol City Councils budget

Opinion: Blue sky thinking not allowed – frustrations of Bristol City Council’s budget

Green councillor for Clifton Down Carla Denyer writes for Bristol 24/7 on the restrictions surrounding the budget process at the council, which she says "makes long-term thinking impossible."

We use cookies on our website to improve your experience, by using our website you accept the use of these cookies. Read More Close