At a council meeting on March 20 Bristol Council debated a petition to ‘Keep our parks advertising free’. The petition was organised in response to the Labour administration’s proposals to introduce commercial advertising to Bristol's parks and green spaces, and calls on the council to abandon these plans.
One month earlier at the council's budget meeting in February, Green councillors had proposed a budget amendment that would have provided extra funding for the city’s parks in order to prevent the introduction of advertising, funded by scrapping the free parking which councillors and senior staff currently benefit from at City Hall. However the amendment was vigorously opposed by all three other parties in the Chamber and voted down by the Labour and Conservative groups.
Responding to the outcome, Green Group Leader Eleanor Combley said:
“To be honest, I struggle to see why this proposal is controversial. Our constitution is clear: the basic allowance for councillors should cover transport costs within Bristol, and we are not meant to receive any additional funding for transport. We seem to have no problem with following this rule when it comes to councillors who use public transport, so why are we going against our own constitution when it comes to councillors who drive?
“It is rather depressing that Councillors value their free parking spaces over increased funding for the city’s parks, which could be used to alleviate threats to introduce advertising. Meanwhile, with no apparent sense of irony, the Labour administration prepares to increase parking charges for ordinary people across Bristol.”
Below is the text of the speech Green councillor for Southville Stephen Clarke made at the March 20 Council meeting, speaking in response to the petition:
Full Council Speech by Cllr Stephen Clarke
"First of all I would like to congratulate the organisers of this important petition (Robbie and Nicola and the others at Adblock Bristol) who I know are doing really important work around the issue of keeping Bristol liveable and helping to protecting our children from some of the pressures imposed by commerce on them.
I suppose the truth is that no one in this chamber really wants advertising hoardings in our parks. The question is whether we are prepared to follow through on this belief or we think it is worth having them to get the cash. My view and the view of my fellow Green Group (and the view of the 5000 odd people who have signed this petition) is that it’s just not worth it.
One of the reasons I love Bristol (which is where I was born and where my children live) is that I am not constantly bombarded by intrusive commercial images; or at least not to the extent that I am in London or New York (or even Liverpool as evidenced by this picture) [image can be seen here].
The thought of brightly lit, large intrusive hoardings in parks trying to sell me goods I don’t want or need fills me with horror. I want (and demand) the freedom to choose when I am exposed to advertising. On ITV, yes; in newspapers and magazines, yes; in parks and public open spaces around the city, NO!
There are many reasons why this idea is disastrously wrong; some have already been mentioned by others but let’s just consider a few fundamental questions:
Firstly; what are our parks for?
- In essence; they are places for urban dwellers to stroll around and have a little taste of nature.
- They are places for parents to bring their kids and allow them to run around with as few cares as possible.
- They are places for our teenagers to chat to each other, exercise on bikes and skateboards and become the citizens of tomorrow.
Secondly; why do the advertisers want to put up these billboards?
- The only reason is obviously to sell us more ‘stuff’; stuff we often don't need; stuff that pollutes our city with noxious fumes like 4x4s; stuff that won’t be making us happy anytime soon.
How do the advertisers do this?
- Usually by attacking how we feel about ourselves; we are made to feel too fat, too old or too poor. Many studies have shown that this directly affects our mental health and leads to problems such as eating disorders, depression and poor self-image.
An even dafter thing to note is that often these advertising campaigns go directly against the aims of our own council initiatives; Sugar Smart for example or trying to help the air pollution situation. Where is the logic in fighting these ills in our town at great cost at the same time as selling opportunities (in our parks!) to accelerate them?
A few other quick points:
- I have a particular concern about digital advertising which I have no doubt will arrive hard on the heels of any billboards that are allowed. These are visual pollution on a huge scale: real ‘sky trash’. They use huge amounts of energy (the large ones have up to 10,000 LEDS and use the same energy as up to 30 residential homes) and are designed to use maximum distraction techniques (of course): quickly changing, brightly coloured visual images bombarding us with sales messages.
- Is it possible to do anything about this issue? Well, we are not the first community to have thought about this; many others have. There is a long list of these forward thinking communities (up to 1400 worldwide at the last count) including all of Sweden, parts of New Zealand, Bergen in Norway, Hawaii and 700 other communities in the USA. All of these and many others have made a stand against billboards and digital advertising.
- By the way; this is a social justice issue too; we might be getting adverts in Dame Emily Park in Ashton or Eastville Park but I don’t suppose we will be seeing them on the Downs any time soon…
The idea of putting advertising in parks is really a crazy one and I really challenge anyone of whatever political persuasion to look in their heart and say it is a good one. To paraphrase the Nike slogan; Just don’t do it!"
- While income predicted from the introduction of advertising in parks is £50k and Cllr Combley’s amendment estimated a £30k income, both are simple estimates and Cllr Combley’s estimate was cautious, predicting that only around half of those who currently have a free permit would pay for one. In her speech to Council proposing the amendment, Cllr Combley said: “In reality, I think £30k is conservative and it would likely be more. If those who spoke against my similar amendment last year are to be believed, the ability to park behind City Hall is so vital that at a price of less than £2 per day we can reasonably expect the take-up to be much higher.”
Did Leave.EU take data from Bristol companies?
Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has today written to Avon and Somerset Police to ask if the force is investigating new evidence that Bristol companies GoSkippy and Eldon Insurance allegedly shared data illegally with Leave.EU.
Green councillors stand with Friends of Redland Library against closure
At a meeting of Friends of Redland Library last week, Green councillors Carla Denyer and Clive Stevens were amongst the speakers updating residents about the progress of the campaign to save Bristol’s libraries.
Brexit update from Bristol's Green MEP
An update from Molly Scott Cato, Bristol's Green MEP and the national EU spokesperson
Keeping Bristol’s parks ad-free
At a council meeting on March 20 Bristol Council debated a petition to ‘Keep our parks advertising free’, in response to the Labour administration’s proposals to introduce commercial advertising to Bristol's parks and green spaces. Green Cllr Steve Clarke spoke in response.
Bristol Uni announces it will become fossil free
The University of Bristol, after extensive talks, announced today that it will withdraw all £700,000 of its investment from the fossil fuel industry. Moving from partial to full divestment is a big step forward for the university, with plans being put in place to ditch all fossil fuel companies from its investment portfolio over the next couple of years.
Council votes for Temple Meads arena location after Green motion
Over five thousand people have now signed a petition calling for the Mayor to support a Bristol arena at Temple Meads. Green councillors brought the matter to a vote with a motion to Full Council.
It’s time for a drug consumption room in Bristol
Green Councillor Cleo Lake is calling for Bristol to launch a drug consumption room to give drug users a safer space with access to needles and specialist support.
Bristol's Three Pro-EU MEPs release joint statement on Russian poison attack
“In a difficult week for pro-EU MEPs, when we debated the next stage of the leaving process, it was heartening to feel the warmth and generosity of our European colleagues in solidarity with the UK in the face of Russian aggression."
Greens bring vote on Arena location to Council meeting
Green Councillors have secured a Council debate and vote on the location of Bristol’s arena at next Tuesday’s Council meeting.
Bristol’s next Lord Mayor announced as Green Councillor Cleo Lake
Green Councillors have announced their candidate for Lord Mayor as Cotham Councillor, Cleo Lake
Clean Air Action Plan proposed after years of Green campaigning
At Bristol Council today, the Cabinet approved the development of a Clean Air Action Plan to tackle the illegal levels of air pollution in the city, which has been estimated to contribute to over 300 premature deaths per year.
High Court refuses MEP's Brexit case
High Court refuses to force government’s hand over Brexit impact studies
Bristol's MEP is today in High Court over Brexit court action
The High Court will this morning hear an oral application for permission to apply for judicial review to compel the production, in public, of the studies the government continues to withhold on the economic impacts of Brexit.
Green Group leader lobbies Treasury for end to local government cuts
Green Group leader Eleanor Combley today travelled to London to hand in a letter to the Treasury calling for an end to cuts to local government funding.
Greens refuse to vote for Labour’s cuts budget
At today’s budget Full Council meeting in Bristol City Hall, the city’s Green Councillors have refused to vote for the Labour Mayor’s austerity budget that proposed cuts of £34 million across Bristol, including library and public toilet closures and a large funding cut to Adult Social Care.
Raft of Green amendments passes at Budget Full Council
Bristol’s Green Councillors are celebrating today as all but one of their budget amendments at today’s Budget Full Council were passed.
Plot to ditch EU food standards threatens South West producers
Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has warned of a plot by leading rightwing Brexiteers to ditch EU food and safety standards that would allow the import of US meats, drugs and chemicals currently banned in Britain.
New report on ‘Britain’s broken housing market’ & lessons from other EU Countries
Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato, has launched a report she commissioned on the UK’s housing crisis.
Opinion: Blue sky thinking not allowed – frustrations of Bristol City Council’s budget
Green councillor for Clifton Down Carla Denyer writes for Bristol 24/7 on the restrictions surrounding the budget process at the council, which she says "makes long-term thinking impossible."
“Build children’s homes instead of sending children across the country”
Green Councillor Eleanor Combley has submitted an amendment to the Council’s budget, calling for two specialist children’s homes to be acquired for children with complex needs. Councillor Combley said: “Bristol’s current children’s homes are too large and unspecialised for children with complex social, emotional or mental health needs, so these children are often sent to homes far from the Bristol area. We know that for most children in care it is better to be closer to home, near their family and communities and where they can be supported by local social workers. In Bristol 1 in 10 children in care are placed more than 20 miles from their home.”
Green councillor welcomes additional landlord licensing proposal
Below is a response from Clifton Down councillor Carla Denyer to the consultation on landlord licensing launched by Bristol City Council today (16 Feb. 18).
Greens offer budget alternatives after lack of "practical or moral leadership” from Mayor
In response to a lack of practical or moral leadership coming from the Labour Mayor’s Office, Bristol Green Party Councillors have today set out a series of suggested positive and progressive alternatives to the council’s annual budgetary hand-wringing process.
20mph proven to be safer in Bristol
An authoritative report produced by the University of the West of England and commissioned by Bristol City Council has demonstrated the safety of the city-wide 20mph zone. Greens are demanding that this should put to bed the debate about the impact of such limits.
Green amendment calls for property developers to fund homelessness prevention
At next week’s budget meeting at Bristol City Council, Green Councillor Carla Denyer will call on the Labour administration to increase emergency funding for some of the most vulnerable people in Bristol, and pay for it by raising charges on private property developments which block roads.
Brexit update from Bristol's Green MEP
A summary of the latest Brexit news from Bristol's Green MEP, Molly Scott Cato
“Don’t repeat the mistakes of the past”– Bundred report one year on
12 months ago the damning ‘Bundred Report’ revealed financial chaos, collective failure of leadership and poor management at the Council. A year on, Green Councillors have written an open letter to the Mayor saying more still needs to be done if the Council is not to repeat the mistakes of the past.
Councillors should give up parking perks to keep our parks ad-free
Green councillor, Eleanor Combley, is calling on colleagues from all parties to give up their free parking spaces at next week's budget meeting, saying the money saved could be used to protect our parks instead.
Bristol's MEP exposes the unholy alliance of ‘Bad Boys’ behind Brexit
Bristol's Green MEP Molly is today launching a website to expose the ‘unholy alliance’ of men behind the campaign to leave the EU. The ‘Bad Boys of Brexit’ website contains details of the coalition of ‘far-right ideologues, climate change deniers, tax-dodging foreign billionaires and specialists in voter manipulation’ who successfully persuaded a majority of the public to vote to leave the EU.
How many times will the police get away with misusing tasers?
Green Party Councillors have responded with shock and dismay to the news that a man with autism was tasered by police in Bristol. The man was charged with assault, before the case collapsed after his mother submitted CCTV evidence which called into question the police officers’ account of the incident.
Green Group leader responds to increase in rough sleeping figures
This year government estimates of rough sleeper numbers rose for the seventh consecutive year. Councillor Eleanor Combley responded to the situation in Bristol.