Green Councillors in Bristol have proposed putting decision making on some major issues in the hands of ordinary Bristolians through ‘Citizens’ Assemblies’ and other forms of participatory democracy.
Citizens’ Assemblies are a way of empowering a representative group of citizens to make decisions on important issues. A group of citizens are carefully selected to be representative of demographics in their area, are given a specific topic to address or problem to solve, and meet multiple times, with access to expert advice, in order to produce policies most of them can agree on. Greens are bringing the proposal to a Full Council meeting on Tuesday 14 January, where it will be first motion to be debated.
The approach can be useful to produce consensus on complicated or controversial issues which politicians might be afraid to deal with effectively. For example, Ireland has convened Citizens’ Assemblies to discuss abortion and same sex marriage, both of which led to referenda and changes in the law.
A pressing issue that a Citizens’ Assembly could tackle is climate change - something which Extinction Rebellion has long called for. Last year Greens proposed the successful motion that declared a Climate Emergency and committed the city to go carbon neutral by 2030. But over a year later they worry there has been little significant progress. They see a Citizens’ Assembly as a way of letting Bristolians lead the way on carbon neutrality, ensuring that nobody in the city is left out of important decisions. And a recent survey shows that 86% of the population of Bristol are concerned about climate change so Greens predict that politicians from other parties will be surprised by how enthusiastic Bristolians are for bold solutions.
In order to set out further details and funding the Green motion calls for the council to set up a working group to determine what types of participatory democracy are established and agree funding for them – with the proposal to trial at least two projects over the 2020-2021 financial year. The working group would include representation from all parties, community groups and people from Bristol’s different communities.
Green Councillor Paula O’Rourke is the motion’s proposer. She said:
“I’m proud to be bringing this motion to next week’s Council Meeting – we’ve got a rare opportunity to break through the usual political process. Democracy doesn’t need to begin and end every few years when you vote. We have a chance to bring people into making the decisions that will affect them and re-energise local democracy.”
In order to support people in taking time from work to take part in a citizen’s assembly and ensure access for those on lower incomes, participants are often paid a stipend. As well as Citizens’ Assemblies, the motion calls for the council to look into participatory budgeting, a way of using a democratic process to allocate part of a local budget. In Paris the process has been used with some success to allocate 5% of the city’s annual budget. Cllr O’Rourke suggests in Bristol it could be trialled with area committees, giving local communities a say in how to allocate fees levied on new developments (known as CIL funding).
“The Mayor often talks about engaging with people outside ‘the bubble’ of City Hall. This motion is a chance to make that a reality and allow ordinary Bristolians a say in making major decisions. I hope all parties will support it.”
Green Group leader councillor Eleanor Combley said:
“I’m delighted we’re bringing this motion to Council – it has the potential to really open up democracy in Bristol. Some people asked us why we did not choose to debate Bristol Airport Expansion again. The honest answer is that we sadly see no sign of Labour changing their position on it, so while we have not given up on campaigning on the issue outside of the council chamber, we are pursuing a new motion at Full Council that we hope has a greater chance of getting the other parties on board and giving ordinary Bristolians a say in how our city deals with the climate emergency and meets our carbon target.
“Labour had the opportunity to debate airport expansion with us at the Full Council meeting in December, but they made their position clear when the Mayor published repeated written statements in support of the expansion, and when they voted with Conservatives to stop that debate.
“If I’m wrong and the Mayor has changed his view on Bristol Airport expansion, it’s up to him to show that by rescinding the statement of support that he sent to North Somerset planning authority and replacing it with clear opposition.”
- The UK government is also convening a national citizen’s assembly following cross party agreement in November 2019. Some 30,000 people were invited from which 110 attendees were selected. See https://www.parliament.uk/business/committees/committees-a-z/commons-select/business-energy-industrial-strategy/news-parliament-2017/citizens-assembly-climate-change-19-20/ for more details.
- See this article https://sharedfuturecic.org.uk/beyond-the-ballot-how-citizens-can-lead-the-climate-change-conversation/ for a useful explanation of how citizen’s assemblies can tackle climate change.
- Extinction Rebellion on Citizens’ Assemblies – from https://rebellion.earth/the-truth/demands/
“Extinction Rebellion believes that part of the problem is the way electoral politics works:
- Political power in the UK is in the hands of a few elected politicians. Over the last 40 years, this system has proved incapable of making the long-term decisions needed to deal with the climate and ecological emergency. Politicians simply can’t see past the next election.
- Members of parliament are lobbied by powerful corporations, seek sympathetic media coverage, and calculate their policies based on potential public reactions and opinion polls. This leaves many of them either unable or unwilling to make the bold changes necessary to address the emergency.
- Opinion polls often gather knee-jerk reactions to loaded questions. They do not allow respondents to become informed or engage with others with different perspectives. For an issue as complex as the climate and ecological emergency, opinion polling won’t cut it.
Here is how a Citizens’ Assembly on Climate and Ecological Justice can break the deadlock:
- A Citizens’ Assembly on Climate and Ecological Justice will empower citizens to take the lead and politicians to follow with less fear of political backlash.
- Citizens’ Assemblies are fair and transparent. Assembly members have an equal chance of being heard. Briefing materials, experts, and other presenters are vetted by diverse stakeholders and shared publicly. This produces informed democratic decisions.
- Citizens’ Assemblies are especially useful when difficult trade-offs are necessary. For example, experts might propose policies for how to meet a 2025 target for net-zero greenhouse gas emissions and the Assembly could decide which they prefer. They would also consider how to mitigate the impacts of changes on the most vulnerable people.”
Call for council to launch green savings bonds for climate action
A Green councillor has called for Bristol Council to launch locally issued investment bonds to fund climate action projects.
Call for Bristol Council to ‘say no to the mow’ in green spaces
Campaigners are calling on Bristol council to reduce grass cutting in verges and green spaces around the city. The move would reduce maintenance costs for the Council and support biodiversity.
A million reasons to oppose Bristol Airport expansion
Following new research showing that planes have three times the impact on the climate when total emissions released at height are properly incorporated, Bristol Green councillors are calling on the Bristol Mayor to rethink his support for Bristol Airport. Bristol City Council will debate this on December 8th 2020.
Greens on WECA: Stop playing blame game and get on with negotiations
Four years after it was set up, local arguments have again flared up over the future of WECA.
Four years later - Bristol is still waiting for clean air
Four years after Bristol City Council unanimously voted to support a clean air zone for Bristol, Bristol’s Mayor has failed to deliver on his promise.
Greens support “Liveable Neighbourhoods”
Green councillors are supporting communities across Bristol who are sick of air pollution and the congestion clogging the streets outside their homes and instead want to create ‘Liveable Neighbourhoods,’ streets where people and business come first, and communities can grow stronger. Liveable Neighbourhoods are supported by a broad network of community groups, including groups representing older people, young people and children, disabled people, people advocating travel by foot or bike, and groups tackling climate change, have come together to form Liveable Neighbourhoods for Bristol https://liveablebristol.org.uk/ to call for change.
“Our house is still on fire” 2 years on from the first UK climate emergency
Marking the 2 year anniversary of the UK’s first climate emergency declaration this Friday 13th Nov, its author, Green Party Councillor Carla Denyer, has decried a lack of action saying that the clock is ticking and “our house is still on fire”.
Council adopts new housing policy for balanced communities
Following almost four years of work by a cross party group of councillors, Bristol Council yesterday (Nov. 3) approved a new planning policy which will allow the Council to support mixed and balanced communities by restricting the proportion of shared houses in areas of the city.
Bristol’s community spirit has never been more needed
Following the announcement that the rising cases of coronavirus across the country mean we will go into a month long lockdown starting on Thursday, Green councillors are supporting calls for people across the Bristol to follow new public health guidance to save lives.
Green councillor takes telecoms giant to task over disruptions
A Green councillor in Clifton Down has secured a commitment from the telecoms giant Openreach to change and enforce their practices in Bristol after raising residents’ complaints with managers from the telecoms company.
Greens sound alarm as Bristol’s air pollution bounces back
Since the end of lockdown, air pollution has begun to rise to dangerous levels again with Bristol city centre already returning to pre-lockdown levels.
Council consulting on city centre Cumulative Impact Area
Bristol Council is consulting on a new Cumulative Impact Area (CIA) in the city centre, which would set licensing restrictions on night time economy businesses like bars, clubs, restaurants and takeaways.
Helping small businesses
Bristol Council is due to step back from levying street trading fees on businesses trading in suspended parking bays during the coronavirus outbreak. Instead of daily fees adding up to approx. £7000 per year, the council will instead request a yearly charge of just £100 for businesses that seek to take advantage of the social distancing measures imposed by the authority to trade in suspended bays. The move follows persistent pressure fro
Motion on reparations blocked as other parties refuse extra time
Cleo Lake's motion calling on Bristol Council to lobby the government over historic slavery reparations and support Bristol's black cultural centres has been dropped from a council meeting
Council to consult on planning changes to prevent overconcentration of student housing
Following three years of work by a cross party group of councillors, Bristol Council is consulting on a new housing planning policy designed to foster mixed and balanced communities
Enslavement reparations needed
A Green Party motion to be debated at next week’s Bristol Council meeting calls on the Council under the Mayor’s leadership to provide more support for black cultural centres in Bristol and to lobby the government to set up an All-Party Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry for Truth & Reparatory Justice which would discuss reparations for the trafficking and enslavement in African people.
Rebooting democracy in Bristol
Two female politicians from different parties have been working together to reboot democracy in Bristol. Green Councillor Paula O’Rourke and Labour Deputy Mayor Asher Craig are leading the ground-breaking new approach of using citizens’ assemblies to help Bristol emerge from lockdown.
Campaigning during COVID
Bristol Green Party statement on current campaigning
Drop street trading fees for local businesses
A petition is calling on Bristol Council to drop charges for local businesses trading in suspended parking bays during the coronavirus outbreak.
#GiveNTech to combat digital exclusion
Working with institutions like Avon Fire Authority and Bristol Waste, Cleo Lake’s #GiveNTech campaign to combat digital exclusion in Bristol been providing laptops to families and individuals since its launch in May.
Greens welcome 'Downs Loop' proposals
A public consultation is under way on proposals for traffic calming and turning worn paths into an accessible loop around the Downs
Citizens Assembly to steer Bristol Covid recovery
Following a motion proposed by Green Councillors in January, Bristol Council is moving forward with plans to carry out a Citizens Assembly
WECA transport plans must “walk the walk not just talk the talk” say Greens
Green councillors have said they are disappointed that WECAs cycling and infrastructure plan “lacks urgency and ambition”.
Greens welcome first steps towards addressing Bristol’s dirty air
Green councillors have welcomed the announcement that next week Bristol bridge, Baldwin Street and Union Street will be closed to through traffic and new bike lanes installed along Park Row, Upper Maudlin Street and Marlborough Street. The changes mark much needed first steps towards improving dangerous levels of air pollution in Bristol. They will also help people move safely about our city during the pandemic by making more room for walking and cycling.
Greens respond to Council licensing changes
Bristol’s Green Councillors have expressed solidarity with communities concerned about the loss of Cumulative Impact Areas, and promised to continue to support the residents they represent.
Greens support trans rights protest 18th July
Cleo Lake welcomes new statue on Colston plinth
Bristol’s former Lord Mayor and artist Cleo Lake welcomed the filling of a ‘political vacuum’ in Bristol by a black woman and black lives matter activist.
Mayor has questions to answer on investment in clean energy
Bristol’s Green Councillors say that the Mayor has tough questions to answer about the City Leap project, which was supposed to be delivering funding for clean energy across the City.
Green Budget Amendment creates more space for foster families
The first family is already benefiting from new rooms in a pilot scheme set up by Bristol City Council thanks to Green councillor Martin Fodor’s budget amendment, which pays for extra rooms in cramped council housing. Bristol has a shortage of larger council houses – the waiting list is twice as long as for smaller properties, and families needing larger homes have to wait for around 2 years.
Cleo Lake to ask Mayor to lobby government over reparations
At a Bristol Council meeting on Tuesday 7 July, Green Councillor Cleo Lake, activist and former Lord Mayor, will ask the Mayor to lobby the government to set up a commission to acknowledge, apologise and instigate reparations for the UK’s role in the Transatlantic Traffic in Enslaved Africans.