Bristol Green Party Logo

Thursday, 12th Jul 2018

How can a Labour Mayor support airport expansion for the few, not the many?

Green councillor Carla Denyer will ask Bristol’s Mayor to reconcile his contradictory views about climate change and airport expansion in light of a new analysis showing that airport expansion disproportionally benefits the wealthiest in society.

The questions, which will be asked at the Full Council meeting on 17th July, read:

1. Does the Mayor understand the critical importance of the UK sticking to its carbon emissions targets, to prevent abrupt and irreversible changes that will wreck livelihoods and make the economy the least of our worries, as we face more of the droughts, crop failures, disease and flooding that we are already seeing on all continents?

2.   In light of the recent analysis that has shown that airport expansion disproportionally benefits the richest 10% while harming us all through climate change, air pollution and noise pollution; and in light of the recently agreed expansion of Heathrow Airport, which puts the UK on a trajectory to miss its carbon emissions targets unless drastic actions are taken; will the Mayor reconsider his previous position of supporting the expansion of Bristol Airport?

Another Green councillor, Charlie Bolton, questioned the Mayor in January 2018, during an earlier consultation about airport expansion, highlighting how the increase in the airport’s capacity – which would see passenger numbers more than double from 8 million to 20 million – contradicts local and national climate targets. At the time he said,

“I asked the Mayor about this at the last Full Council and in response he suggested he supports both meeting our climate targets and expanding the airport, which is quite frankly impossible to reconcile. Making encouraging sounds about climate commitments while blithely agreeing to more air travel is trying to have your cake and eat it. Much like Theresa May it seems the Mayor simply doesn’t want to face up to the unpleasant reality that our climate change targets are incompatible with further expanding airports and air travel in the UK."

"Political evasion on this issue isn’t helping anyone.”

Councillor Denyer has also submitted a motion to next week’s Full Council meeting, calling on the Mayor to use his influential position to hold the airport to account on its emissions, to ensure the region keeps its commitments. The Joint Spatial Plan – which includes North Somerset and the geographical area covered by the airport – contains an explicit commitment to making a 50% cut in emissions by 2036. But the airport has been accused of ‘greenwash’ for publicising a 2030 carbon neutral target with no plan in place, and which does not include the emissions from aeroplanes themselves.

She commented: “This is an equality issue as well as an environmental one. According to the Civil Aviation Authority’s passenger surveys, 47% of the UK population has flown in the last year, and this figure has been stable over the last 15 years. Most of those people only make one or two trips per year, while 10% of the population makes about 60% of all flights, and these people are mainly from the highest income groups. This means that airport expansion disproportionally benefits the wealthy but negatively affects us all through climate change, air pollution and noise pollution. So I cannot understand how a Labour Mayor can justify his position of backing airport expansion.”

In the recent vote in Parliament over the expansion of Heathrow, Bristol’s Labour MPs were divided, with two voting against, one voting for, and one not present.

Notes:

- Councillor Denyer’s exposé of the Airport’s misleading claims and lack of a plan for decarbonisation: https://bristolgreenparty.org.uk/news/bristol-airport-carbon-targets-worthless-without-roadmap-say-greens

- Councillor Bolton’s question to Marvin Rees in January 2018, during the last round of the consultation, and the Mayor’s answer: https://bristolgreenparty.org.uk/news/greens-say-we-all-need-to-challenge-airport-expansion. This was covered in Bristol Post here: https://www.bristolpost.co.uk/news/bristol-news/mayor-marvin-rees-is-having-1116930

 - Votes cast by MPs on the Heathrow expansion: https://metro.co.uk/2018/06/26/mp-voted-heathrow-expansion-debate-parliament-7659718/

 - Full text of question and motion submitted to next week’s Full Council meeting (Tuesday 17th July) below

 

Question - Councillor Carla Denyer: Bristol Airport expansion

1.            Does the Mayor understand the critical importance of the UK sticking to its carbon emissions targets, to prevent abrupt and irreversible changes that will wreck livelihoods and make the economy the least of our worries, as we face more of the droughts, crop failures, disease and flooding that we are already seeing on all continents?

 2.            In light of the recent analysis that has shown that airport expansion disproportionally benefits the richest 10% while harming us all through climate change, air pollution and noise pollution; and in light of the recently agreed expansion of Heathrow Airport, which puts the UK on a trajectory to miss its carbon emissions targets unless drastic actions are taken; will the Mayor reconsider his previous position of supporting the expansion of Bristol Airport?

Sources:

•             IPCC Climate Change 2014 Synthesis Report Summary for Policymakers: http://ar5-syr.ipcc.ch/topic_summary.php

•             News article about the IPCC 2014 reports: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/mar/28/ipcc-report-climate-change-report-human-natural-systems

•             Analysis showing that airport expansion will increase inequalities: https://theconversation.com/heathrows-third-runway-is-expensive-polluting-and-unequal-why-the-poor-will-lose-out-98781

•             News article about the very high chance of missing the UK climate change targets if Heathrow expansion goes ahead: https://www.independent.co.uk/infact/heathrow-airport-expansion-vote-third-runway-climate-change-chris-grayling-a8415881.html

 

FULL COUNCIL MOTION – 17 July 2018 - Expansion of Bristol International Airport and Climate Change

Full Council notes:

  1. The stage 2 consultation by Bristol Airport regarding a new Master Plan and Charter for Future Growth (which could cover the period up to the mid-2040s); and the further consultation which will be launched this winter.
  2. That these proposals include a more-than-doubling of passenger numbers from the current figure of 8 million to 12 million in the next few years and then 20 million.
  3. That the proposals include an aspiration to be carbon neutral by 2030 (printed next to a photograph of an aircraft engine, implying that emissions from flights would be included).1
  4. That upon investigation it was found that the Airport currently lacks any plan for how to achieve carbon neutrality, and has no intention to include emissions from flights in its target.2
  5. That air travel remains the most climate-damaging form of travel, and significant expansion of air travel will therefore have a significant climate impact.
  6. That such an increase will lead to an enormous increase in the number of journeys to get to the airport to meet the increased usage – a fact which in itself will lead to significant issues around congestion, pollution and infrastructure.
  7. The commitment – in Bristol – to be carbon-neutral by 2050, and the Climate Change Act which requires an 80% cut in emissions across the UK.
  8. The Joint Spatial Plan – which includes North Somerset and the geographical area covered by the airport– contains an explicit commitment to making a 50% cut in emissions by 2036.
  9. The widespread concern that the expansion of Heathrow Airport which was supported by MPs on 25th June will make it even harder to meet the UK’s commitments under the Climate Change act.3
  10. That airport expansion, whether in Bristol or Heathrow, locks the UK into emissions increases.
  11. That 47% of the UK population has flown in the last year, and this figure has been stable over the last 15 years. Most (31%) only make one or two trips per year. This means that 10% of the population makes about 60% of all flights, and these people are mainly from the highest income groups.4

Full Council believes that:

  1. Airport expansion disproportionally benefits high income households while negatively affecting all households through climate change, air pollution and noise pollution.
  2. The airport must conform to the commitment contained in the Joint Spatial Plan, and such a commitment must include emissions from the aircraft using it.

Full Council resolves to call on the Mayor to: 

  1. Pass on these views to the airport, North Somerset Council, the West of England Combined Authority, the Joint Committee; and
  2. Respond directly to the consultations making the points above.

Motion Submitted by: Councillor Carla Denyer

Date of submission: 5th July 2018

Motion Notes

  1. See page 19 of https://static1.squarespace.com/static/59b6667ab7411c6d0214b1f3/t/5af5823e03ce6466ca11df4d/1526039116734/Stage+2+booklet+ELECTRONIC+FINAL.PDF
  2. Copy of correspondence between Councillor Carla Denyer and the Bristol Airport Consultation Team. https://bristolgreenparty.org.uk/library/Appendix_-_Airport_emails.pdf
  3.  The Committee on Climate Change found that the UK target of reducing emissions by 80 per cent below 1990 levels could be achieved only if emissions from the UK aviation industry do not exceed 37.5 million tons – the level seen in 2005. And yet, a report released by the Department for Transport has already revealed that aviation emissions will hit 43 million tons by 2030 if the Heathrow expansion goes ahead. https://www.independent.co.uk/infact/heathrow-airport-expansion-vote-third-runway-climate-change-chris-grayling-a8415881.html
  4. Calculated by David Banister based on the National Travel Survey data and the Civil Aviation Authority’s Air Passenger Surveys: https://theconversation.com/heathrows-third-runway-is-expensive-polluting-and-unequal-why-the-poor-will-lose-out-98781
Helping small businesses

Helping small businesses

Bristol Council is due to step back from levying street trading fees on businesses trading in suspended parking bays during the coronavirus outbreak. Instead of daily fees adding up to approx. £7000 per year, the council will instead request a yearly charge of just £100 for businesses that seek to take advantage of the social distancing measures imposed by the authority to trade in suspended bays. The move follows persistent pressure fro

Motion on reparations blocked as other parties refuse extra time

Motion on reparations blocked as other parties refuse extra time

Cleo Lake's motion calling on Bristol Council to lobby the government over historic slavery reparations and support Bristol's black cultural centres has been dropped from a council meeting

Council to consult on planning changes to prevent overconcentration of student housing

Council to consult on planning changes to prevent overconcentration of student housing

Following three years of work by a cross party group of councillors, Bristol Council is consulting on a new housing planning policy designed to foster mixed and balanced communities

Enslavement reparations needed

Enslavement reparations needed

A Green Party motion to be debated at next week’s Bristol Council meeting calls on the Council under the Mayor’s leadership to provide more support for black cultural centres in Bristol and to lobby the government to set up an All-Party Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry for Truth & Reparatory Justice which would discuss reparations for the trafficking and enslavement in African people.

Rebooting democracy in Bristol

Rebooting democracy in Bristol

Two female politicians from different parties have been working together to reboot democracy in Bristol. Green Councillor Paula O’Rourke and Labour Deputy Mayor Asher Craig are leading the ground-breaking new approach of using citizens’ assemblies to help Bristol emerge from lockdown.

Campaigning during COVID

Campaigning during COVID

Bristol Green Party statement on current campaigning

Drop street trading fees for local businesses

Drop street trading fees for local businesses

A petition is calling on Bristol Council to drop charges for local businesses trading in suspended parking bays during the coronavirus outbreak.

GiveNTech to combat digital exclusion

#GiveNTech to combat digital exclusion

Working with institutions like Avon Fire Authority and Bristol Waste, Cleo Lake’s #GiveNTech campaign to combat digital exclusion in Bristol been providing laptops to families and individuals since its launch in May.

Greens welcome Downs Loop proposals

Greens welcome 'Downs Loop' proposals

A public consultation is under way on proposals for traffic calming and turning worn paths into an accessible loop around the Downs

Citizens Assembly to steer Bristol Covid recovery

Citizens Assembly to steer Bristol Covid recovery

Following a motion proposed by Green Councillors in January, Bristol Council is moving forward with plans to carry out a Citizens Assembly

WECA transport plans must walk the walk not just talk the talk say Greens

WECA transport plans must “walk the walk not just talk the talk” say Greens

Green councillors have said they are disappointed that WECAs cycling and infrastructure plan “lacks urgency and ambition”.

Greens welcome first steps towards addressing Bristols dirty air

Greens welcome first steps towards addressing Bristol’s dirty air

Green councillors have welcomed the announcement that next week Bristol bridge, Baldwin Street and Union Street will be closed to through traffic and new bike lanes installed along Park Row, Upper Maudlin Street and Marlborough Street. The changes mark much needed first steps towards improving dangerous levels of air pollution in Bristol. They will also help people move safely about our city during the pandemic by making more room for walking and cycling.

Greens respond to Council licensing changes

Greens respond to Council licensing changes

Bristol’s Green Councillors have expressed solidarity with communities concerned about the loss of Cumulative Impact Areas, and promised to continue to support the residents they represent.

Greens support trans rights protest 18th July

Greens support trans rights protest 18th July

Cleo Lake welcomes new statue on Colston plinth

Cleo Lake welcomes new statue on Colston plinth

Bristol’s former Lord Mayor and artist Cleo Lake welcomed the filling of a ‘political vacuum’ in Bristol by a black woman and black lives matter activist.

Mayor has questions to answer on investment in clean energy

Mayor has questions to answer on investment in clean energy

Bristol’s Green Councillors say that the Mayor has tough questions to answer about the City Leap project, which was supposed to be delivering funding for clean energy across the City.

Green Budget Amendment creates more space for foster families

Green Budget Amendment creates more space for foster families

The first family is already benefiting from new rooms in a pilot scheme set up by Bristol City Council thanks to Green councillor Martin Fodor’s budget amendment, which pays for extra rooms in cramped council housing. Bristol has a shortage of larger council houses – the waiting list is twice as long as for smaller properties, and families needing larger homes have to wait for around 2 years.

Cleo Lake to ask Mayor to lobby government over reparations

Cleo Lake to ask Mayor to lobby government over reparations

At a Bristol Council meeting on Tuesday 7 July, Green Councillor Cleo Lake, activist and former Lord Mayor, will ask the Mayor to lobby the government to set up a commission to acknowledge, apologise and instigate reparations for the UK’s role in the Transatlantic Traffic in Enslaved Africans.

Clean air is a right not a luxury

Clean air is a right not a luxury

“Our right to clean air is as basic and important as our right to clean drinking water. It’s now nearly 4 years since the Council passed a Green motion calling for a Clean Air Zone and yet despite the Council spending millions of pounds on consultants, Bristol is no closer to clean, breathable air. After four years of failure from Marvin Rees to act on clean air, I fully support protesters taking peaceful socially-distanced action to voice their frustration at the city's continuing illegal and unsafe air quality and call on the Mayor to speak with the protesters to explain just how he intends to clean up Bristol's air, with the urgency that is needed."

Good progress on homelessness but MPs must do more nationally

Good progress on homelessness but MPs must do more nationally

Green councillor and Bristol West MP candidate Carla Denyer has praised staff at Bristol City Council for their work tackling homelessness during lockdown [1], but highlighted that some more radical changes are still needed to fix the UK’s broken housing system. Councillor Denyer has called on the Government to do all it can to support renters, but has also made a particular plea to local Labour MP and Shadow Housing Secretary Thangam Debbonaire to reconsider her party’s proposals [2], which seem to favour landlords over their tenants.

Green Councillor Carla Denyer named one of the top women in engineering

Green Councillor Carla Denyer named one of the top women in engineering

Green Councillor Carla Denyer has been named as one of the Top 50 Women in Engineering for 2020 by the Women’s Engineering Society.

Bristol needs clean air now

Bristol needs clean air now

As Extinction Rebellion gears up for a week of action and protests around Bristol’s illegal air quality levels, Green Councillors say clean air is now more important than ever. With growing evidence that dirty air exacerbates the impact of coronavirus and growing calls for a nationwide review on the Government’s air quality strategy, Greens say the time for talking is over – immediate action is now needed to clean up Bristol’s dangerous air.

Prevent a second wave of Coronavirus  give Bristol tools to track and trace

Prevent a second wave of Coronavirus – give Bristol tools to track and trace

As lockdown restrictions are eased in Bristol, early evidence suggests the government’s ‘track and trace’ program is not reaching enough people to be effective.

Let this mark a new era for Bristol

Let this mark a new era for Bristol

Green Party Councillors in Bristol and the Green mayoral candidate join the voices calling for a new era to begin, now that Colston's statue, and the oppression it represents, no longer looks out over Bristol.

Safe streets needed now

Safe streets needed now

As more people return to work and children return to school it is more important than ever that we have streets that prioritise pedestrians and cyclists and enable social distancing, Bristol’s Green Councillors have said.

Greens of Colour call for independent COVID inquiry to factor in institutional racism

Greens of Colour call for independent COVID inquiry to factor in institutional racism

Green Party demands independent BAME Covid-19 inquiry: The Green Party has backed calls for an independent inquiry into the disproportionate impact of Covid-19 on black, Asian and minority ethnic people. Greens of Colour chairperson Azzees Minott said: “The government’s inquiry into the impact of Covid-19 on BAME people has let communities of colour down.

Tackle rising unemployment with a Green New Deal

Tackle rising unemployment with a Green New Deal

Green councillors have been calling for a ‘Green New Deal’ to reboot the economy, provide jobs and tackle the climate crisis. On 2nd June Bristol City Council's Cabinet meeting included the news that the Council is forecasting a funding gap of around £86 million as a result of the Coronavirus pandemic. This is made up of a combination of loss of income and additional expenditure to pay for the response to the emergency. Unemployment is also forecast to rise steeply in coming months.

Bristols carbon neutral 2030 target essential

Bristol's carbon neutral 2030 target essential

Green Councillor Carla Denyer proposed Bristol Council’s original Climate Emergency motion – the first of its kind in Europe – in November 2018. She said: “Hidden away on page 107 is a warning that there is now a high risk of failure to deliver the Council’s Climate Emergency Action Plan to reach carbon neutrality by 2030. This is very concerning. We cannot afford to lurch from one emergency to another. Some form of Green New Deal is essential to help the city and country to ‘build back better’. A green recovery is the only way to deal with the huge economic challenges while tackling the climate crisis, creating security and leaving behind the inequality that has damaged our society for so long.”

Secrecy and concealment as Bristol Energy loses millions of pounds

Secrecy and concealment as Bristol Energy loses millions of pounds

Bristol Energy has lost tens of millions of pounds of Council tax payers money, so Greens ask why this week's Cabinet meeting will hold the discussion's on what has gone wrong in secret.

Cleo Lake launches GiveNTech campaign to tackle digital exclusion

Cleo Lake launches #GiveNTech campaign to tackle digital exclusion

Green Councillor Cleo Lake has launched a campaign to redistribute unused IT equipment to tackle digital exclusion during pandemic

We use cookies on our website to improve your experience, by using our website you accept the use of these cookies. Read More Close